Secrets and Mysteries: Sense & Sensibility Read-Along, Chapters 10-25

All right! Now we get into the meat of the story, and all Jane Austen’s moralizing begins. The first nine chapters were really just setting the stage.

Here are the chapters, if you want to listen to them first.














So, Marianne and Willoughby are boldly and blatantly enraptured with each other, and only Elinor seems to see anything untoward in this. She has to talk Marianne out of accepting the gift of a HORSE (of all things) from Willoughby, and scolds her for going with Willoughby all over Allenham Court, with nobody home but old Mrs. Smith. Oddly enough, the affront here seems to be more to Mrs. Smith for entering her house without an invitation than for going to such a private place with Willoughby. Meanwhile, Colonel Brandon really starts to fall for Marianne, now that he sees her with someone way more attractive than himself. He grows in mystery, as he hints at a tragic past involving a young lady… Elinor refers to him as amiable, so we know he must be a good ‘un. And THEN, of a sudden, just as they are all going out on a picnic, he gets a note that has him depart on the spot. He will not be persuaded to delay even a day.

BUT that is not the big news! Enter Lucy Steele for some real drama and antics. She is neither well-bred nor warm-hearted nor amiable nor ill-disposed. I believe she is what we call a minx, or something like it. (Aside: note how suspicious Austen is of her interest in the children. The heroines take no notice of them, but the villainous Lucy is all over them!) And now Elinor has to take on her wretched secret while struck with the blow of discovering that Edward is lost to her forever! Lucky thing she was so discreet about her feelings. At least we now know why he wouldn’t confess his love to Elinor, and we can account for the oppression of spirits which always confused her. (Also note this same phrase “oppression of spirits” is used to describe Colonel Brandon, and it is suggested that neither character is naturally dull, but seems to have something weighing on them to make them so.)

Marianne, on the other hand, gets to weep her heart out when Willoughby mysteriously takes off, just as it seemed he was going to propose. I mean, he took a lock of her hair! (That’s pretty extreme in Regency times, not to mention the HORSE!)

And in their reactions to bad news, Austen uses the sisters to illustrate the two approaches to sentiment that she wishes to contrast, though it is clear which side she is on.


This book really is about Sense and Sensibility. And I believe that Austen got the title from Mary Wollestonecraft, whom she undoubtedly would have read. Here is a little quote from Wollestonecraft about women: “Their senses are inflamed, and their understandings neglected; consequently they become the prey of their senses, delicately termed sensibility, and are blown about by every momentary gust of feeling. They are, therefore, in a much worse condition than they would be in, were they in a state nearer to nature. Ever restless and anxious, their over exercised sensibility not only renders them uncomfortable themselves, but troublesome, to use a soft phrase, to others. All their thoughts turn on things calculated to excite emotion; and, feeling, when they should reason, their conduct is unstable, and their opinions are wavering, not the wavering produced by deliberation or progressive views, but by contradictory emotions. By fits and starts they are warm in many pursuits; yet this warmth, never concentrated into perseverance, soon exhausts itself; exhaled by its own heat, or meeting with some other fleeting passion, to which reason has never given any specific gravity, neutrality ensues.”
Am I justified in this belief? Do share.
So, one mystery solved (i.e. what was up with Edward and his hot-cold routine with Elinor), and several new ones begun (i.e. what’s up with Willoughby vamooshing like that? Are they or are not they engaged? What took Brandon off so suddenly? What is his history?)
Oh, and let us not forget the joy of the Palmers! I think Emma Thompson must have been divinely inspired to think of Hugh Laurie for that role, for though Ang Lee directed the film, I’m sure she had a lot to do with the casting. I know Alan Rickman always wanted to play a romatic hero, but could never get away from playing bad guys all the time. And she and Hugh Laurie are old buddies from Cambridge… that crew all are.  

In her desire to see everyone married, Mrs. Jennings insists on taking Marianne and Elinor to London under the ruse that her house will be too empty since her second daughter is now married. And so away they go. 

Note Lucy’s bad grammar (never a good sign in an Austen novel). And who else loves the character of Anne Steele? You can almost see Lucy rolling her eyes every time she opens her mouth. 

I have read this book and seen this film so many times that I can’t remember what I surmised the first time I read it. Any newbies here care to offer a prediction? 

I would like to offer my theory about the fact that Jane Austen published this novel without her name attached to it. It was authored by “A Lady.” Theories abound as to why this was, whether she wanted to remain anonymous for reasons of pride, of privacy, of class, whether it was proper for her to be writing novels, etc. My own suspicion is that her reasons were ones of politeness. In Regency times, and up until even the 20th Century, a woman’s first name was quite a private and personal thing. It was not simply bandied about. There were very specific rules about who could call a lady by her Christian name and in what circumstances. Jane Austen would have been generally referred to as Miss Jane Austen, her elder sister, Cassandra, being called Miss Austen. However, when Cassandra was not there, or not in contemplation, Jane could have been called Miss Austen. Her family and close friends would have called her Jane (or possibly Jenny, as suggested in a letter from her mother announcing her birth). Married women took their husband’s names in public, like Mrs. John Dashwood, who is only called Fanny by family members. So, for an unmarried woman, the question of how to style themselves in relation to a publication was probably quite complicated. For men, it was not such a big deal. Their whole names were used much more frequently as their lives were sort of more public. A lady publishing a book was in something of a novel position (forgive the pun). Nobody would simply call her Jane Austen, especially not strangers. That would be very rude and inappropriate. To call her Miss Jane Austen on a book cover would be awkward and strange, because nobody reading her book would even know she had a sister. But Miss Austen would be inaccurate because of that sister nobody knew about. Much easier just to say “A Lady” and I think the public was fine with this. They got it. “I am a lady, and I am not putting my name on this book to be passed among the public and spoken casually by strangers.” It was a dignity thing, in my opinion. 

But, onwards and upwards! What is to happen in London? Find out here, or on YouTube, or anywhere else you are choosing to follow along. Happy trails as you go!

20 comments

  • Micah S. Martin
    Micah S. Martin California
    The reaction times (dark to-dim) of present day [url=https://monitorbee.co/]Monitor Bee[/url] ​screens are normally around 2-5ms. This makes them ideal for watching films and messing around, and you'd be hard-pushed to see any diverting following or ghosting. In spite of this, the reaction times are being pushed considerably further as innovation improves. OLED screen reaction times, for instance, are relied upon to be around 0.01ms or even lower.

    The reaction times (dark to-dim) of present day Monitor Bee ​screens are normally around 2-5ms. This makes them ideal for watching films and messing around, and you'd be hard-pushed to see any diverting following or ghosting. In spite of this, the reaction times are being pushed considerably further as innovation improves. OLED screen reaction times, for instance, are relied upon to be around 0.01ms or even lower.

  • Benjamin E. Saville
    Benjamin E. Saville London
    The issue is tracking down a [url=https://guruwalik.com/best-movies-to-watch-on-hbo/]hbo[/url] demonstrated web website design enhancement composing master is truly challenging on the grounds that they are often grabbed up by the bigger web optimization organizations.

    The issue is tracking down a hbo demonstrated web website design enhancement composing master is truly challenging on the grounds that they are often grabbed up by the bigger web optimization organizations.

  • Harold M. Wright
    Harold M. Wright India
    Hirsuteness, brought about by an [url=https://headsetpro.co/best-headset-for-movies/]10 Best Headset For movies in 2021[/url] augmentation of the hair follicle and the obscuring and thickening of hair, is an undeniable condition that can influence one's mental self view a lot regard.

    Hirsuteness, brought about by an 10 Best Headset For movies in 2021 augmentation of the hair follicle and the obscuring and thickening of hair, is an undeniable condition that can influence one's mental self view a lot regard.

  • Cassie J. Villalpando
    Cassie J. Villalpando Hungary
    He's already back to playing Minecraft on camera (-ish) and if he's willing to enjoy himself at this moment, I think we should be willing to join him in that sentiment, even if I'm wrong and he actually does have low survival chances. [url=http://technoblade.biz/]technoblade[/url]

    He's already back to playing Minecraft on camera (-ish) and if he's willing to enjoy himself at this moment, I think we should be willing to join him in that sentiment, even if I'm wrong and he actually does have low survival chances.
    technoblade

  • Brahim
    Brahim UK
    However, tons to our amusement, amongst these lie plenty of double-crossing web sites.[url=https://www.thededicatedengineer.com/make-money-online-reddit/]https://www.thededicatedengineer.com/make-money-online-reddit/[/url] These websites pitch their schemes so effects that it makes you work day and night time–handiest to leave you feeling ‘excessive and dry’ as soon as awoke from the cringeworthy revel in.

    However, tons to our amusement, amongst these lie plenty of double-crossing web sites.https://www.thededicatedengineer.com/make-money-online-reddit/
    These websites pitch their schemes so effects that it makes you work day and night time–handiest to leave you feeling ‘excessive and dry’ as soon as awoke from the cringeworthy revel in.

  • Andrew smith
    Andrew smith united states
    Amazing blog it is full of knowledge and informative content dude I really like it good work keep it up https://www.danezon.com/category/tv-series-jackets/all-american-jackets/

    Amazing blog it is full of knowledge and informative content dude I really like it good work keep it up https://www.danezon.com/category/tv-series-jackets/all-american-jackets/

  • Kirestin Gregory
    Kirestin Gregory USA
    Secret and mysteries are having the proper sense of log reading is necessary for every person no matter living in which part of the love and the real happiness comes after the marriage life of the person. The page is about the title new in which the couple has the [url=https://www.resumehelpaustralia.com/]https://www.resumehelpaustralia.com/[/url] picture of their cool and relaxes setup and arguments.

    Secret and mysteries are having the proper sense of log reading is necessary for every person no matter living in which part of the love and the real happiness comes after the marriage life of the person. The page is about the title new in which the couple has the https://www.resumehelpaustralia.com/ picture of their cool and relaxes setup and arguments.

  • james bond
    james bond USA
    I saw your videos you have a great knowledge your all blog is very informative thank you for sharing with us [url=https://www.jacketpop.com/product/mens-cafe-racer-dark-blue-leather-jacket.html]Mens Navy Blue Leather Jacket[/url]

    I saw your videos you have a great knowledge your all blog is very informative thank you for sharing with us Mens Navy Blue Leather Jacket

  • peter shawn
    peter shawn new york
    Very nice Article Keep it up for your good Work Thanks for sharing information The content was really very interesting. I am really thankful to you for providing this unique information You have a good point here! [url=https://www.nyjacket.com/product/kanye-west-yeezy-gap-black-jacket/]Yeezy Gap Black Jacket[/url]

    Very nice Article Keep it up for your good Work Thanks for sharing information The content was really very interesting. I am really thankful to you for providing this unique information You have a good point here! Yeezy Gap Black Jacket

  • peter shawn
    peter shawn usa
    It is highly informative and builds great interest for the readers. For the people like us your blogs helps to get ideal information and knowledge. [url=https://www.theusasuits.com/product/ted-lasso-jason-sudeikis-jacket/]afc richmond jacket[/url]

    It is highly informative and builds great interest for the readers. For the people like us your blogs helps to get ideal information and knowledge. afc richmond jacket

  • Duane
    Duane usa
    Your blog is very nice Wish to see much more like this. Thanks for sharing your information! I bookmark your blog because I found very good information on your [url=https://www.usajacket.com/product/bengals-starter-jacket/]bengals starter jacket[/url]

    Your blog is very nice Wish to see much more like this. Thanks for sharing your information! I bookmark your blog because I found very good information on your bengals starter jacket

  • Dorothy P. Palmer
    Dorothy P. Palmer London
    Vape pen users enjoy the convenience and portability a vape pen affords them. At [url=https://www.vapeape.com/]vapeape[/url], you can find the right kind of vaporizer to suit your lifestyle.

    Vape pen users enjoy the convenience and portability a vape pen affords them. At vapeape, you can find the right kind of vaporizer to suit your lifestyle.

  • zack
    zack USA
    Thank you for making my day [url=https://bedouinsoapopera.com/]Natural Soap[/url]

    Thank you for making my day Natural Soap

  • Mia Bright
    Mia Bright Minim possimus mole
    The treatment for hair misfortune due to cornrow braids is fluctuated. You can apply Minoxidil on the scalp region for a [url=https://poshglad.com/collections/fauxlocsbraids]faux locs[/url] of months and check whether there are any perceptible changes or then again look for a specialist's recommendation. The other regular strategies, for example, utilization of natural meds can likewise be attempted as they have less aftereffects than synthetics.

    The treatment for hair misfortune due to cornrow braids is fluctuated. You can apply Minoxidil on the scalp region for a faux locs of months and check whether there are any perceptible changes or then again look for a specialist's recommendation. The other regular strategies, for example, utilization of natural meds can likewise be attempted as they have less aftereffects than synthetics.

  • Maia Hewitt
    Maia Hewitt Fugiat nulla dolori
    Not at all like the game improvement racket, these control rackets will provide you with a ton of control. These kind of rackets tend be adjusted [url=https://www.padelracchette.it/]Padel Racchette[/url] head light to expand the mobility of a weighty stick. The consequence of this mix can be a low-power racket that is ideally suited for players who make their own power.

    Not at all like the game improvement racket, these control rackets will provide you with a ton of control. These kind of rackets tend be adjusted Padel Racchette head light to expand the mobility of a weighty stick. The consequence of this mix can be a low-power racket that is ideally suited for players who make their own power.

  • Carmen Hodges
    Carmen Hodges
    The [url=https://www.seotoolsaccess.net/]SEO tools like ahrefs semrush group buy[/url] are among the best shared SEO tools. The Backlink Analysis tool offers functional data about all backlinks to any domain. It provides charts that show how many new and lost backlinks a particular domain has. It also offers information on the evolution of the backlink generating process. You can choose to subscribe to any of the three plans, starting with $5.

    The SEO tools like ahrefs semrush group buy are among the best shared SEO tools. The Backlink Analysis tool offers functional data about all backlinks to any domain. It provides charts that show how many new and lost backlinks a particular domain has. It also offers information on the evolution of the backlink generating process. You can choose to subscribe to any of the three plans, starting with $5.

  • Ali
    Ali pakistan
    Best blog website thank you for sharing with us [url=https://www.siwtech.com/]web development services[/url]

    Best blog website thank you for sharing with us web development services

  • williams
    williams USA
    What an amazing website thank you so much for permitting me to comment keep going on [url=https://ralphskin.com/]Ralph Skin[/url]

    What an amazing website thank you so much for permitting me to comment keep going on Ralph Skin

  • ZANAT
    ZANAT UK
    Pelvic inflammatory sickness, or PID, takes place [url=https://www.emboardbombs.com/]https://www.emboardbombs.com/[/url]whilst lady reproductive organs come to be inflamed. The reproductive gadget is the a part of the frame involved in getting pregnant and having a toddler.

    Pelvic inflammatory sickness, or PID, takes place https://www.emboardbombs.com/whilst lady reproductive organs come to be inflamed. The reproductive gadget is the a part of the frame involved in getting pregnant and having a toddler.

Add comment